Advertising

Home Entertainment

 

Planar PD8150

July 11, 2008 By Geoffrey Morrison



Click the images below for bigger versions:
Planar PD8150
Planar PD8150 Back
Planar PD8150 Back Panel

Color from Glossy Black

Whatever you do, don't touch the PD8150. This is not, as you're certainly expecting, because it will bite you. Once your installer mounts it and wipes it off, leave it alone. This is because the stylish, gloss black case attracts fingerprints like a Hummer attracts scornful glances. There's even a handy cloth in the case to clean it. But once it's up there (out of reach), the color that comes out of it is something to behold.

There is something to be said about a company that creates a product with the mindset of “lets make this thing accurate." There are many tricks to fudge the numbers game that is the projector market, and none of them start with being accurate. Yet this is just what Planar set out to do with the PD8150.
Planar PD8150
Ground, Up
From the beginning, Planar wanted to have the PD8150 be as accurate as possible out of the box. Few companies design products this way, even though most enthusiasts will agree that an accurate display looks far, far better than an inaccurate one. Of all the displays I've measured over the years, only a handful have had accurate color points out of the box. One such display was the InFocus 777, which probably isn't too surprising as many members of that product's design team are now at Planar.

This isn't to say that you shouldn't have the display calibrated, different screens have different color shifts, but it does mean that it’s natively a lot closer to accurate than most other displays. Colors will appear natural (and they do), skin tones will be realistic (very), and the overall image just seems realistic. Less like you're watching a display. I watched it for a few days before calibrating it, and it looked great, but after calibration it looked a little better.

Contrast
Based on the latest generation of DLP chips from Texas Instruments the PD8150 sports the now-normal 1,920 by 1,080 resolution. Like many of its brethren, the PD8150 sports an auto-iris, here known as DynamicBlack. This feature looks at the incoming video signal, and then opens or closes a shutter in the light path to dim the light in dark scenes, and open up for bright scenes. This helps the overall contrast ratio, making very dark scenes appear darker, and bright scenes brighter.

Normally these types of auto-iris systems don't do anything to the actual contrast ratio within any given scene (as in the streetlights on a dark street). DynamicBlack, on the other hand, runs the bright areas of an image a little hotter, potentially increasing contrast in a scene as well. Personally, I found that this system tracked the signal a little too closely, causing some pulsing of the brightness. I tend to be over sensitive to auto-iris functions, so you may not notice it at all. Even so, with DynamicBlack switched off, I found the contrast to be on par with other DLP projectors, which is to say good, if not great. Light output was also good, though not as bright as some. Black level is decent, but not as good as the class leading LCOS projectors.

ProcessingPlanar PD8150 Remote
The PD8150 uses the Gennum GF9450 chip for the processing duties. It passes all the standard deinterlacing and scaling tests with little problem. It took a little longer than normal to pick up the 3:2 sequence with 1080i content, but not overly. With 480i, it was able to create a respectable amount of detail from this lower resolution content, and picked up the 3:2 sequence here very quickly.

Overall detail was excellent, with the projector having no problems recreating a 1-pixel on/1-pixel off test pattern.

The PD8150 brought out more noise from my cable feed than other projectors I've had in recently. The noise reduction circuitry did a good job smoothing much of this out, without over-softening the image. With content that had no inherent noise, the PD8150 didn't add any.

Blu-ray movies and PS3 games like Gran Turismo 5 Prologue looked excellent. The color was the most notable part of the image. With accurate color points, close-ups of people looked that much more realistic. Shots of grass and trees looked natural and less like what we’ve sadly become used to these days. Enough so that at first glance, the PD8150 may seem less vibrant than its competition. On further watching, though, the relaxing aspect of true-to-life colors becomes addictive.

Curviness
The curvy case is attractive and fairly solidly build, better than some at this price point, though not up to the standard set by Sony in this category (few do). It is reasonably quiet, quieter than many DLP projectors.

All in all the PD8150 puts out an attractive, accurate image. When the competition seems to be pushing hard to out do each other with the most oversaturated and crazy "300% Color" claims, it's refreshing to find an entry into the field that takes a step back and just says, "shouldn't it look like this? Isn't this what the movie looked like?" Indeed.

DESCRIPTION
Single-chip 1080p DLP front projector; requires separate projection screen.

CONNECTIONS
Two HDMI (1.3) digital video inputs, two component video inputs, one RGB-PC input, one s-video, one composite, one IR remote input, two 12-volt triggers, one RS-232 serial port for external control systems

DIMENSIONS
7.6 x 17.7 x 20.6 inches (hwd)

PRICE/CONTACT

Price: $7,999
Contact: 866.752.6271, planarhometheater.com

Planar PD8150

Comments

That's a tough call, as both are excellent projectors. The Samsung is going to be a little more accurate, but the Planar will have a better dynamic contrast ratio (only because of the iris) and better de-interlacing. See if you can demo both. Otherwise, you really can't go wrong with either.

I'm narrow my research down to 2 projectors. Geoffrey which projector would you choose between the Planar PD8150 vs the Samsung SP-A800B. thanks, hope to hear from you soon.

Advertising

Advertising

Subscribe Today!

Subscribe today to Home Entertainment, and get a FREE GIFT - with “Just ask - the 5 questions you should ask before hiring a custom installer”.

 

Advertising

Browse Professionals

American Automation & Communications
Bowie, MD
(301) 352-2400
New York, NY,
(888) 2022-5600
Englewood, CO,
(303) 484-8237

Advertising